Week Seventeen Picks
Picking week seventeen is always a giant pain in the patoot. Between the teams with nothing to play for and lots of reasons to rest starters, the teams that have checked out, and teams that might want to finish strong but might not have the ability to pull it off, you tend to end up with half a slate of games where no amount of analyzing stats and trends will do you a bit of good. And even in a season when the playoff picture didn’t come together until late, that’s what we have this weekend. I see a handful of outright gimmes (Atlanta is beating Carolina; it’s that simple); a handful of shrugs (I don’t care if there’s a division title on the line, St. Louis-Seattle is an outright yawn); and a bunch of games where there’s absolutely no (accurately) guessing what might happen. Here’s what not to expect. (Or maybe this time it’s what to expect. How would I know?)
Miami (+3) at New England
This game would be a lot easier to pick if either team had an incentive to win. They don’t. The Patriots are locked in as the AFC’s one seed. And while it’s highly unlikely that Bill Belichick will rest starters for the sake of resting starters, it’s also unlikely that he’ll pass up the opportunity to give some key backups at least a bit of real-game experience as he prepares his squad for a post-season run. I expect to see Brian Hoyer lining up under center by the start of the fourth quarter. The Dolphins, meanwhile, have nothing to play for. Their season ends officially at the close of this game, though it was pretty clear last weekend that a number of players already had packed it in. I’m gonna make the assumption that the Patriots probably only need to play one half of serious football to put the Dolphins far enough in the rearview to hold on and win. Assuming they’ll do that, I’ll take New England and give the points. But you never really know with a game like this.
Buffalo (+3) at NY Jets
The Frat Boys may have something to play for on paper, but in reality, it’s nothing. New Jersey is in the playoffs win or lose. With a win and a Ravens win and a Steelers loss, the Frat Boys would move up from the six seed to the five. But it’s meaningless. They’re playing at Kansas City, Indianapolis or Jacksonville next weekend no matter what happens in the Meadowlands this Sunday. And which team hosts the wild card game will depend on what happens in those teams’ season finales, so there’s nothing to be gained by trying to pick an opponent. New Jersey also has a beat-up quarterback who may start the game but won’t finish it. So there’s that. The only pro football team that plays (most of) its home games in New York, meanwhile, is coming off a really embarrassing loss and likely feeling they’ve got something to prove, if only to themselves, before another long off-season begins. I expect the Bills to play hard and the Frat Boys not to, which leads me to think we’ll get an upset. It’ll happen late and it’ll be by a narrow margin – maybe just a point – but it’ll happen just the same.
Cincinnati (+9.5) at Baltimore
The Bengals shocked pretty much everybody by ending the Chargers’ season (excuse me while I wipe away a tear) last weekend. But don’t get too caught up in wondering if Cincinnati will be able to play spoilers again. The Bengals are still an awful team. And the Ravens go into this game with an outside chance (they need a win and a Steelers loss) at the AFC two seed and a first-round bye. That, plus Cincinnati’s complete inability to stop the run, should make for a fairly easy Baltimore victory. I’m rarely comfortable giving more than a touchdown in a divisional matchup, but I think 10 here is reasonable.
Tampa Bay (+8) at New Orleans
OK, so we can agree that the Saints aren’t getting the NFC South title and the one seed, right? Because that would require the Falcons to lose at home to the worst team in football, which simply isn’t gonna happen. That makes New Orleans the NFC five seed and puts them on the road at either St. Louis or Seattle a week from now. (That’s a win for the Saints.) And that means the Saints have nothing to play for here. The Buccaneers, on the other hand, have at least a phantom to chase: If they win and the Giants and Packers both lose, the Bucs are in as the six seed. They’re not getting there, of course, but that doesn’t mean the won’t try. That’s why, though I think the Saints would like to finish strong badly enough that they’ll probably play a full game and come out ahead, I like the Buccaneers to keep the margin to something closer to, say, three.
Carolina (+14.5) at Atlanta
The worst team in football travels to face a 12-3 squad that’s a win away from securing home field advantage through the NFC playoffs. You need something more than that? Atlanta by 20.
Minnesota (+7) at Detroit
The Vikings had a nice turn Tuesday night in Philadelphia, but I think the key verbiage there is “Tuesday night.” It’s hard enough to play back-to-back road games in the NFL. It’s tougher still if the second outing is against a divisional opponent. And it’s gotta be a complete killer when there’s just five days in between. I’d be taking the Lions straight up here either way – they’re far better than the Vikings offensively, only slightly worse defensively, and they protect the ball a whole lot better – and under the circumstances, I’m not even hesitant to give the seven points.
Oakland (+4) at Kansas City
From the perspective of post-season seeding, the Chiefs don’t have a lot to play for in this game. They can protect the three seed with a win, but that probably doesn’t mean all that much unless you want to make sure someone else has a shot to knock off New England before you have to travel there. But I don’t see Todd Haley taking his foot off the pedal (or letting his players take their feet off). Momentum means too much to a team in the Chiefs position. Plus, there’s never been a whole lot of love lost between Kansas City and Oakland. Both offenses rely heavily on the run, but the Chiefs have a defense that can actually stop it. Kansas City also takes much better care of the ball. I’m taking the Chiefs and giving the points.
Pittsburgh (-6) at Cleveland
I know there are more than a few people out there who believe, for whatever reason, that the Browns have the potential to play tough and deny their rivals a division title and a first round bye. I’m not one of those people. I look at the Browns and I see a team with an increasingly banged up running back, a likely lame duck head coach and, most importantly, no ability whatsoever to so much as slow down an opponent’s running attack. That doesn’t add up to a hard-fought Cleveland victory; it adds up to Pittsburgh getting a week’s rest. Steelers by nine.
Jacksonville (-1) at Houston
Quick: Who’s got a guess as to which foot the Texans will shoot themselves in this week? Because with David Garrard out and Maurice Jones Drew probably out, there’s very little reason to believe the Texans shouldn’t win this game. Thing is, the mere fact that the Texans should win has very little meaning. There have been a lot of games this season that the Texans should have won but didn’t. And there where it becomes impossible to pick this thing: You can’t expect either of these teams to win, but there’s no way for both of them to lose. I’m taking Houston because I can’t figure out a reason to pick Jacksonville. But I won’t tell you I feel good about that, because I don’t. I just really, really don’t.
Arizona (+6.5) at San Francisco
I’m having a very hard time getting my head around the decision to fire Mike Singletary. I mean, not in general. The 49ers are hosting a battle for last place in the worst division in professional football. A change was in order. But in advance of week seventeen? What’s the point? You finish the season and then you make a change at the top. Or, you know, that’s how sane organizations do it. Whatever. I don’t want to pick the 49ers, but I really can’t pick the Cardinals. So I’ll take San Francisco straight up and Arizona with the points. As if anybody cares.
Chicago (+10) at Green Bay
The Bears can say whatever they want, I’ll believe they’re “full go” for this game when I see it. Because assuming (once again, and just as safely) that there’s no chance the Falcons lose to the Panthers, the Bears’ last incentive to put it all on the line this weekend disappeared when Vikings upset the Eagles Tuesday night. The Bears are the NFC two seed. They’re getting a week off and they’re hosting at least one playoff game. And they’re not capturing the one seed. They’ve got nothing to play for here. The Packers, on the other hand, have everything to play for. If the Pack wins, they’re in. (And they get an all-expenses-paid wild card weekend trip to Philadelphia, where they will be pummeled mercilessly! Hooray!) That should be enough to carry Green Bay to victory over a team they’d have little chance of beating under normal circumstances. But I ain’t giving no 10 points. Four seems more like it.
Tennessee (+9.5) at Indianapolis
If I were Bud Adams and had to choose between Jeff Fisher and Vince Young, I’m not sure I’d find the decision too difficult. You stick with the proven pro, right? The guy who’s shown he knows how to win over the guy who can’t even show he knows how to do his job? Well, maybe that’s how people like you and I think. Bud Adams, not so much. Which means we can look forward to many more seasons of the Titans sucking. That’s good news for the Colts and Jaguars, I suppose. As for this game, uh, yeah, sure, I’ll give the points. Might as well.
San Diego (-3.5) at Denver
Hey, Chargers, I really enjoyed your game last week. Got a message for you from Nelson Muntz. But you know what? You go ahead and enjoy this easy win – and your off season. San Diego by a touchdown.
Dallas (+7) at Philadelphia
I can’t see giving seven points considering that the Eagles will be playing on five days rest, with a banged up quarterback and nothing to play for (win or lose, they’re the conference three seed). But I can’t pick the Cowboys to win on the road, either. So I’m looking for the Eagles to come out ahead by a field goal.
NY Giants (-4) at Washington
The Giants need help to get into the playoffs and I rather suspect they’re not gonna get it. But they shouldn’t need much help to take out their frustrations on a Washington team that does next to nothing well. Giants by six.
St. Louis (-3) at Seattle
I’ve gotta be honest. I’m rooting for Seattle in this game. Why? Because if one of these awful teams is gonna win a division, I want it to be the one that does it with a losing record. That’s 6-9 Seattle. Of course, my rooting isn’t gonna help the Seahawks overcome their inability to move the ball, inability to score, inability to stop opponents from scoring, and inability to protect the ball. Those things should add up to St. Louis winning the game and winning the NFC West at 8-8. It’s a push with the points.